WhatsApp

Article

The dirty secret of clean megawatts: why CCGT cooling water chemistry makes or breaks efficiency

beta-pramesti-asiaindustry-power-generation-combinedprocess-ccgt

In CCGT (combined‑cycle gas turbine) power plants, up to ~95% of intake water can be lost through evaporation—making chemical control decisive for efficiency, cost, and compliance. The key: stable high COC (cycles of concentration), coordinated scale‑corrosion inhibitors, and a robust biocide program.

In fact, open recirculating cooling systems in CCGT plants operate under high heat loads with very large water volumes—and chemical discipline is the main line of defense. In industrial cooling tower systems, up to ~95% of makeup water can be lost as evaporation, and the rest is discharged as blowdown. Reducing blowdown by raising COC (cycles of concentration, the ratio of salt concentration in recirculating water to makeup water) directly cuts makeup water demand and effluent.

A clear example: a study of a 1,000-ton cooling tower showed that raising COC from 2.2 to 4.0 cut annual blowdown from ~8.08 million to ~3.23 million gallons (down −60%), and to ~1.08 million gallons at 10×COC (−85%). In Indonesia's tropical climate (warm, humid), which worsens scaling and biological growth, this water conservation is increasingly critical (www.mdpi.com).

The chemical program must also comply with local regulations—for example, PerMenLH 08/2009 limits cooling tower blowdown to pH 6–9 with free Cl₂ ≤1.0 mg/L and PO₄³⁻ ≤10 mg/L (www.scribd.com). This means a balanced high-COC program is needed to protect heat transfer, suppress scaling/corrosion, control biofouling, and meet effluent quality standards.

Scale-control regime and inhibitors

Mineral scale (CaCO₃, CaSO₄, Ca₃(PO₄)₂, silica) quickly insulates heat exchanger surfaces and reduces efficiency. These salts tend to deposit on hot surfaces (retrograde solubility) or at locations with high local pH, such as cathodic sites. The simplest operation is to keep the bulk water unsaturated (low COC or acid injection)—but this is water-intensive.

Modern practice has moved to threshold inhibitors that allow high COC without scaling. Commercial programs combine organic phosphonates and dispersant/growth-inhibitor polymers:

- Secondary phosphonates (organophosphorus inhibitors such as HEDP, ATMP, NTMP) adsorb onto newly formed crystals, inhibit nucleation and crystal growth, and chelate Ca²⁺/Fe²⁺. Typical doses are only a few ppm—about 2–10 mg/L as PO₄ equivalent—and give significant inhibition without stoichiometric dosing. By contrast, chelants such as EDTA almost require a 1:1 dose with Ca, which is difficult for hard water.

- Dispersant polymers and growth inhibitors (for example polyacrylates, polyvinyl phosphonic acids, maleic/LAS polymers) keep crystals suspended. In the field, phosphonates and polymers are blended to target CaCO₃, CaSO₄, silica, and others—exactly like the commonly used package of industrial cooling tower chemical program, scale inhibitors for cooling tower, and dispersant.

Performance evidence: a combination of flexible polymers and crystal growth inhibitors keeps heat exchanger tubes “essentially free” of corrosion and deposits after program conversion. A high-COC strategy that combines softened makeup water also reduced the CaCO₃ formation rate to nearly zero in trials. For difficult silica scenarios—which are less affected by conventional inhibitors—periodic acid cleaning or RO pretreatment is sometimes needed; options such as Brackish Water RO can serve as pretreatment.

Phosphate and silica note: phosphate in circulation can accumulate, while environmental limits (e.g. 10 mg/L in Indonesia) restrict phosphate addition (www.scribd.com), so modern programs often limit orthophosphate and rely on polymer modifiers.

Outcome: a maintained tower can run at 4–8× COC without fouling, while systems without protection are often limited to 2–3×. For Indonesian conditions (high hardness/humidity), this means avoiding repeated cleaning and outages. In makeup water, softening with a softener is often used to push COC higher.

Multi-metal corrosion inhibition strategy

Cooling loop materials in CCGTs are usually mixed: carbon steel piping, stainless or cupronickel condenser tubes, and brass/admiralty in tower sections. An effective program combines pH control and inhibitors to protect all surfaces at once—in line with the corrosion inhibitors package for cooling tower applications.

- pH control (~8–8.5): most open recirculating systems run at slightly alkaline pH to suppress general corrosion. At pH ~8.2, a thin CaCO₃ film often forms and passivates steel. Corrosion rate rises sharply below pH 7 or above ~9. Alkalinity is maintained (e.g. with caustic or amine) so pH stays in the upper-7 to mid-8 range without driving heavy scaling—with a neutralizing amine option such as neutralizing amine.

- Anodic inhibitors (nitrite, molybdate): for ferrous circuits, nitrite (NaNO₂) at hundreds of ppm is the standard. The industry maintains ~500–1,000 mg/L nitrite for full passivation of steel, with steel corrosion rates falling below ~0.5 mpy (mils per year; 1 mil = 0.001 inch). Molybdate is an alternative at ~1/3 the nitrite dose. Both need a little dissolved oxygen to form a protective oxide; nitrite can trigger nitrifying bacteria and nitrosamine formation with amines, so an oxidizer and/or alternative chemicals are used alongside.

- Cathodic/filming inhibitors (amine, phosphate, silicate): some programs add phosphate or silicate as a cathodic inhibitor, but environmental effluent issues limit this. Some plants use filming amines (e.g. octadecylamine or morpholine) to coat steel; this also helps with pH control. Modern non-phosphate polymeric programs often include proprietary filming agents and silicate.

- Copper/aluminum protection: copper/brass alloys require passivation with an azole (benzotriazole/tolyltriazole) that adsorbs and forms a passive film. If the dose is maintained, copper corrosion is almost zero—lab coupons show <0.2 mpy in well-treated systems. Note: chlorination and some treatments consume azole, so the dose must be maintained; alternative oxidizers such as chloramines or ClO₂ are sometimes chosen to avoid rapid film degradation.

- Heavy metal restrictions: older programs used Zn or chromate, now banned. Indonesian regulations prohibit Zn and Cr(VI), and even Cu discharge is tightly limited (www.scribd.com). So modern chemistry avoids soluble Zn or chromate—the trend is toward non-phosphate/non-zinc polymer programs.

Outcome: at 10×COC with optimized chemistry, steel corrosion is ~0.25–0.5 mpy and copper alloy corrosion is ~0.01 mpy. In practice, maintained condenser loops usually show coupons ≤0.5 mpy. Monitoring dissolved iron/copper and pH confirms passive conditions; keeping [Cl⁻] well below the pitting threshold is also standard. A complete cooling tower chemical package and precise dosing with a dosing pump help achieve this consistency.

Biological control and biofilm management

Cooling towers are an ideal habitat for microorganisms. Biofilm that forms in the fill and heat exchangers can cut heat transfer drastically, even by up to half, and trigger Legionella (www.mdpi.com). Scale and biofilm work in synergy: deposits protect bacteria and Legionella—“stagnation, biofilm and scale enhance Legionella survival and multiplication” (www.mdpi.com), so scale control is part of microbiological control. CDC emphasizes that “scale, corrosion, sediment controls, and system cleaning are critical” for [Legionella prevention](https://beta.co.id/en/blog/a-tropical-perfect-storm-inside-the-palm-oil-industrys-cooling-tower-plan-to-beat-legionella) (www.cdc.gov).

Oxidizers: chlorine (gas/NaOCl/HOCl), bromine, chlorine dioxide (ClO₂), or ozone are commonly used. In practice, an oxidizer residual is maintained in the basin (e.g. 0.2–0.5 mg/L free Cl₂) plus periodic higher-dose “shock”. Studies show that continuous chlorination alone is not sufficient (www.mdpi.com), but the addition of periodic hyper‑chlorination reduces Legionella by 1–2 log (p<0.05) (www.mdpi.com). Guidelines (CDC/ASHRAE/etc.) recommend continuous feed via a metering pump and a shock schedule (www.mdpi.com) (www.cdc.gov). ClO₂ is often selected in high-flow systems because it produces fewer stable chlorides and a longer residual (www.mdpi.com). For a safe and stable chlorine supply, the electrochlorination option (making NaOCl from brine) is operationally relevant.

Non-oxidizers: aldehydes (e.g. glutaraldehyde), isothiazolinone, guanidine, THPS, and others work more slowly but can penetrate thick biofilm and are not neutralized by organic load. Common strategy: continuous oxidizer (low dose) plus 2–3 weekly pulses of non-oxidizer (e.g. 5–20 mg/L glutaraldehyde). THPS is often used at a 3–5 mg/L release, or DBNPA at ~5 mg/L based on product technical documentation. Non-oxidizers are important when chlorine alone fails, as in the illustration of H₂O₂/Ag failure in one test (www.mdpi.com). The right biocides package, combined with continuous feed using a dosing pump, provides broad-spectrum control.

Monitoring: HPC (heterotrophic plate count) and Legionella specifically are monitored; the CDC practice target is HPC <10⁴ CFU/mL and Legionella not detected. Disinfectant residual is tracked (free Cl₂ or ORP/oxidation-reduction potential). To support chemical control as well as effluent compliance (free Cl₂ ≤1.0 mg/L), many plants dechlorinate blowdown or switch to ClO₂ (www.scribd.com). Products such as dechlorination agent, UV sterilizers such as ultraviolet, or filtration help reduce chemical consumption and support compliance.

Outcome: an effective biocide regimen drastically reduces microbial fouling. The same study recorded Legionella falling from ~10⁶ to ~10³ CFU/L with a shock/continuous combination (www.mdpi.com). A well-maintained tower shows no visible slime and HPC several times lower than without treatment.

Integrated program and performance indicators

- COC: monitored via conductivity or TDS. Target ≥4–6× COC with stable chemistry. Increasing COC from ~2×→4× has been shown to cut blowdown by about half. Regular blowdown testing ensures mineral accumulation stays below the saturation margin. Pretreatment of suspended solids with media such as sand/silica filter helps keep the circuit clean.

- Corrosion: coupons or electrical probes are installed in the condenser loop; typical targets are ≤1 mpy for steel and undetected copper loss. If it rises (>1 mpy steel), inhibitor dose is adjusted. On-spec industrial operations usually record 0.2–0.5 mpy.

- Scale: regular inspection of pump strainers, heat exchanger delta‑T, or rising pressure drop serves as an early warning. Ideally, mechanical cleaning is no more than annual; with a crystal growth inhibitor program, deposit cleaning intervals can stretch to 6–12 months—and industrial cooling tower cleaning services help schedule them. The right strainer device adds visibility into field conditions.

- Microbiology: weekly/monthly measurements—target a one-order-of-magnitude reduction after program changes; for example, a Legionella target below 50 CFU/L in recirculating water, and HPC in the thousands per mL range or lower under treatment. Control charts provide assurance of microbiological health.

- Cost/compliance: every improvement in condenser pressure (kPa/bar) or drop in cooling water temperature (°C) lowers heat rate and increases output at multi-hundred-MW plants. By preventing scale and keeping the condenser clean, BFW purity is maintained and performance stays at design. Data-based outcomes: 60% blowdown reduction, fouling reduction >80%, steel corrosion <0.5 mpy, and Legionella reduction >90%. Compliance with PerMenLH 08/2009 is mandatory—e.g. keeping phosphate and heavy metals below thresholds (www.scribd.com).

- Industry trends: utilities are moving to digital monitoring (online sensors for ORP, conductivity, microbiology), which can be supported by Monitoring Cooling Tower Sentinel CTS. Non-phosphate chemistries and biofilm inhibitor blends are increasingly preferred over older methods. For challenging makeup (hardness/silica), membrane options such as nano-filtration or membrane systems packages can be considered as pretreatment toward high COC.

Technical and compliance summary

[Coordinated chemical program](https://beta.co.id/blog/menjinakkan-menara-pendingin-pabrik-sawit-resep-kimia-terkoordinasi-untuk-panas-tinggi-dan-air-kaya-organik)—threshold inhibitors (phosphonate/polymer), corrosion passivators (nitrite/molybdate/azole), and strong biocides—are the “insurance” for large-capacity CCGT cooling systems. Data and field practice show that such a program can cut blowdown, practically eliminate scale, hold corrosion at sub-mpy, and suppress Legionella >90% (www.mdpi.com). In Indonesia, this evidence-based approach improves efficiency/reliability while ensuring effluent compliance (e.g. chloride/phosphate limits) (www.scribd.com).