Article
CCGT cooling towers are thirsty. Two moves are cutting that bill fast
Water-Thirsty CCGT: Saving Thousands of Cubic Meters with High Cycles and Treated Wastewater
Running cooling towers at the highest possible cycles of concentration (COC)—without scaling—and switching makeup to treated wastewater dramatically reduces a CCGT's water footprint. Field data show water savings of tens of percent and fast payback.
A combined-cycle gas turbine (CCGT) plant with a wet cooling tower consumes large volumes of fresh water: typical evaporation loss is 0.5–1.0 L/kWh (www.mdpi.com), and one case is ~0.74 L/kWh—equivalent to ~2.8×10^6 m^3/year for a large plant (www.mdpi.com).
Globally, industry is the largest water user (~45% of total abstraction), and ~80% of that is for cooling (www.sciencedirect.com). As water scarcity increases—the IPCC estimates that ~50% of the population will experience water stress in 2025 (www.mdpi.com)—CCGT operators are encouraged to shrink their water footprint.
For cooling towers, the answer is clear: maximize COC (cycles of concentration, the ratio of circulating water TDS to makeup) and use non-traditional makeup sources. DOE guidance emphasizes that the goal of water efficiency is to “maximize COC” safely (www.energy.gov).
COC definition and operating limits
COC measures how intensively water is reused; the higher the COC, the lower the blowdown (discharge of some circulating water to limit salt accumulation) and makeup. DOE notes that many towers operate at 2–4 COC, but with adequate treatment “6 cycles or more may be possible” (www.energy.gov).
The water impact is real: raising COC from 3 to 6 cuts makeup by ~20% and blowdown by ~50% (www.energy.gov). A target of “COC as high as possible” means just below the threshold for unacceptable scale/corrosion.
Scale, corrosion, and biofouling control
A higher COC raises TDS, Ca, Mg, and silica—and the risk of scale precipitation. Common strategy: acid injection to lower pH and convert carbonate alkalinity to bicarbonate (allowing higher COC) (www.energy.gov), scale/corrosion inhibitors, and good makeup water quality.
Removing hardness via ion exchange opens the way to high COC without scale—with softened makeup, the scale threshold shifts to a higher COC, provided the chemical program is well managed. Implementation of this practice commonly starts with an ion-exchange-based softener and then a chemical program of scale inhibitors and corrosion inhibitors.
Without softening, acid/chemical consumption rises sharply. Automatic control of conductivity, the Langelier Saturation Index (LSI; an indicator of scale/corrosion potential), and side‑stream filtration help—an LSI near zero (slightly corrosive) indicates minimal deposit risk. To monitor conductivity, pH, and blowdown alarms continuously, Sentinel CTS for cooling tower monitoring is available.
In practice, 5–10 micron particle filtration with media such as sand silica dual media and polishing via cartridge filter are often installed to control fouling. Precise chemical dosing is supported by a dosing pump. In freshwater systems, blowdown conductivity is often below ~4,500 µS/cm (www.sciencedirect.com).
The water benefit is substantial: lowering hardness (Ca/Mg ions) via ion-exchange resin allows high COC without scale.
Direct water savings from high COC
DOE also estimates that doubling cycles from 3 to 6 cuts blowdown by ~50% (www.energy.gov).
Alternative makeup sources and reuse
Besides raising COC, the use of non‑freshwater makeup effectively reduces drinking water use. DOE guidance mentions air‑handler condensate, once‑through cooling drain, industrial rinse/process water, stormwater, and—most relevant—treated municipal/industrial wastewater (www.energy.gov). Good-quality municipal effluent is cited as suitable for makeup (www.energy.gov).
In practice, many power plants—especially in dry regions (Southwestern US, Florida, Middle East)—already use secondary/tertiary wastewater for cooling (www.powermag.com) (www.mdpi.com). An extreme example, Singapore's “NEWater” (>5 million people) supplies industry and returns to the cooling system (www.mdpi.com). In Indonesia, reuse regulations exist but enforcement is weak—adoption of global best practices is needed (www.mdpi.com).
For pre-treatment, membrane combinations such as ultrafiltration and brackish water RO are common in industrial reuse; upstream, biological-membrane integration such as membrane bioreactors (MBR) produces reuse-quality water for cooling makeup.
TSE case: Aramco to US utilities
A Saudi Aramco pilot study tested TSE (treated sewage effluent; secondary-treated municipal wastewater) as makeup (www.watertechonline.com). TSE (TDS ≈1,500 mg/L, Ca ≈106 mg/L) has lower scaling potential (Langelier index ~0–0.5) than the previous groundwater (TDS ≈3,040 mg/L, Ca ≈233 mg/L), which caused severe condenser scaling at 2 COC (www.watertechonline.com).
As a result, the tower can operate at 3.5 COC vs 2.0 previously—cutting water demand by ~27% (www.watertechonline.com). In absolute terms, the 1,200-ton pilot saves ~16,500 m^3/year; if expanded to 5,000–6,000 tons of cooling, the potential is ~82,500 m^3/year (plus ~82,505 kWh of energy) (www.watertechonline.com).
Pathogens controlled: Legionella, coliform, and viruses were not detected through continuous chlorination and biocide (www.watertechonline.com). Condenser surfaces remained clean (no mineral deposits), leading to the conclusion that “TSE is a viable and sustainable alternative” as makeup (www.watertechonline.com) (www.watertechonline.com). A program like this requires a robust chemical package such as biocides and scale inhibitors, including a dechlorination step when needed.
In the US, a 1,800 MW CCGT uses 100% secondary-treated municipal effluent (phosphate 13 ppm) as tower makeup (www.powermag.com). By switching to a specialized polymer treatment, the plant removed the need for side-stream lime softening—avoiding CAPEX of $5–10 million—and achieved net O&M savings of ~$0.75–1.0 million/year (www.powermag.com) (www.powermag.com). The key: reclaimed wastewater must be managed carefully—chloride, ammonia, and organic levels trigger biofouling; high phosphate promotes calcium phosphate scale (www.powermag.com). With pre-treatment (filtration, dechlorination) and specialized chemistry, performance can be equal or better—without condenser scaling (www.powermag.com) (www.powermag.com).
Cooling tower blowdown recycling
Treating blowdown as a “water source” is also effective. Research shows that treated blowdown reuse (RO/UF/activated carbon) reduces system water consumption by ~13% and is more cost‑effective than upgrading makeup (www.sciencedirect.com). This architecture aligns with industrial membrane systems packages; element selection, for example membrane RO, is carried out according to blowdown characteristics.
An aggressive example: a 750 MW CCGT in Chile piloted an RO–crystallizer system and achieved 96% blowdown recovery (www.watertechonline.com). Almost zero liquid discharge, COC can be pushed very high—limited by inlet quality—and the plant demonstrated continuous operation for 30 days, recovering the CTBD stream that previously went to an evaporation pond (www.watertechonline.com) (www.watertechonline.com).
Cost, water tariffs, and ROI
Indonesian industrial water tariffs are the benchmark. For large users (e.g. Jababeka), the tariff is around US$0.60–0.80/m^3 (123dok.com). By comparison, Jakarta’s domestic tariff for consumption >20 m^3 comes to ~Rp5,550/m^3 (~$0.36) (megapolitan.kompas.com)—indicating that industry pays more.
Every 1,000 m^3 saved is worth ~$600–800 (excluding sewer). If a 500 MW CCGT uses ~3.7×10^6 m^3/year, a 20% makeup reduction (≈0.74×10^6 m^3) saves ~$444–592 thousand/year; at $1/m^3 it becomes ~$740 thousand/year. Savings on blowdown disposal and chemicals add value (DOE: water savings versus chemical costs must be compared; acid adds labor/H₂SO₄ costs, while high COC can increase inhibitor requirements) (www.energy.gov).
A typical package contains an ion exchange unit and cooling tower circuit protection chemicals.
In the Saudi pilot, chlorine at 1.5–2.5 mg/L kept health risk low at negligible additional chemical cost (biocide was already dosed continuously) (www.watertechonline.com). For reuse/blowdown treatment, the right membrane configuration—for example, a UF/RO module—determines OPEX and efficiency; flow, pressure, and temperature monitoring of the UF/RO system can use Sentinel WT.
Aggregating benefits and hypothetical scenarios
Combining the methods doubles the benefits. Using TSE plus raising COC means freshwater purchases for cooling approach zero. Hypothetical illustration: if a plant saves 1×10^6 m^3/year of drinking water, at $0.6/m^3 that is $600 thousand/year; if the project (piping + treatment) costs $2 million, payback is ~3–4 years (shorter if it includes blowdown disposal savings and incentives). Partial recycle (e.g., 50% blowdown) can also cut intake by more than half.
In summary, high cycles and reuse “minimize freshwater intake” and are cost‑effective under water scarcity conditions (www.sciencedirect.com) (www.powermag.com).