WhatsApp

Article

The Disinfection Trade‑Off: Chlorine, ClO₂, Ozone, or UV?

beta-pramesti-asiaindustry-municipal-waterprocess-primary-dan-secondary

Chlorine, ClO₂, Ozone, or UV? A Map of Performance and Cost in Drinking Water Disinfection

EPA/WHO data show a performance gap: 1-log Giardia requires a CT of 42 mg·min/L with chlorine at 10°C—ozone needs only ~0.48 mg·min/L. But DBP, residual, and cost make the choice less simple than that.

Chlorination has been the backbone of drinking water disinfection for more than a century. It is inexpensive, easy to operate, and leaves a protective residual in the distribution network. But the regulatory burden of disinfection by-products (DBP) and resistant pathogens such as Cryptosporidium are pushing utilities to reconsider: is it time to switch to chlorine dioxide (ClO₂), ozone, or ultraviolet (UV)?

For utility managers and design engineers, the answer lies in the combination of “effectiveness vs DBP vs cost”. Note: CT (concentration×time) is expressed in mg·min/L; UV dose in mJ/cm²; 1-log means 90% inactivation.

Chlorination (free chlorine): classic performance, DBP problems

Chlorine (a strong oxidant) is effective at killing bacteria and many viruses at doses of 1–4 mg/L within minutes and at low cost (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). But at practical doses it is essentially ineffective against chlorine-resistant protozoan cysts such as Cryptosporidium (WHO).

EPA guidance notes that for 1-log (90%) inactivation of Giardia at 10°C, a CT of ~42 mg·min/L is required with chlorine (for example, 1 mg/L for 42 minutes), while ozone requires only ~0.48 mg·min/L under the same conditions—see the table in the source (nepis.epa.gov) (nepis.epa.gov). Bacteria are the easiest to kill; viruses require moderate doses (some enteric viruses such as adenovirus require higher doses or alternative methods) (WHO) (nepis.epa.gov).

DBPs are the chemical cost of this convenience. Chlorine reacts with natural organic matter (NOM) to form THMs (for example, chloroform) and HAAs; hundreds of other DBPs (haloacetaldehydes, halonitriles, etc.) are also known (WHO). Regulatory limits are strict: WHO sets several hundred μg/L as the upper range for THM safety (for example, 200 μg/L for chloroform), while the US EPA limits total THMs to 80 μg/L as an illustration of the concern (WHO). In practice, TOC/precursor control becomes a necessity—this area is usually supported by granular filtration such as activated carbon and sand/silica filter media before disinfection.

From an implementation standpoint, chlorination is the cheapest in capex and energy. A gas or hypochlorite feeder installation with a contact tank can cost only a few thousand dollars for a small plant; NRC calls it “inexpensive and relatively convenient to produce, store, transport, and use” (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). Annual chemical costs are moderate—a few hundred dollars per million gallons treated. Operation: very low energy, with automatic chemical feed via a feeder such as a dosing pump. Many PDAMs also use on‑site solutions such as electrochlorination for hypochlorite supply.

Advantages: very low cost, high reliability, and a protective residual in the distribution network (the residual is established as free chlorine or chloramine) (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). Disadvantages: DBP formation (THM/HAA) and weak effectiveness against Cryptosporidium; chlorine gas also poses a safety risk (toxic, corrosive). To meet modern DBP limits, utilities often add precursor removal or multi‑barrier treatment. Note: chloramine or chlorite-based providers can minimize THMs, but chloramine is generally only a secondary disinfectant and forms other DBPs such as nitrosamine (WHO). Because of low cost and a residual that is easy to maintain (via hypochlorite or chloramine formation), chlorination remains globally dominant—historically ~95% of systems in the US used chlorine (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov), and the majority of PDAMs in Indonesia also depend on chlorine.

Chlorine dioxide (ClO₂): broad spectrum, no THM

ClO₂ is a stronger oxidizer than chlorine and is effective against bacteria, viruses, and protozoa over a wide pH range (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) (nepis.epa.gov). EPA guidance shows ClO₂ is ~4× more effective than chlorine for Giardia (e.g., 1‑log CT ~21 mg·min/L for Cl₂ vs ~5.7 mg·min/L for ClO₂ at 10°C) (nepis.epa.gov). At 20°C, the gap narrows: chlorine ~21 mg·min/L vs ClO₂ ~7.7 mg·min/L (1‑log) (nepis.epa.gov). For a number of viruses (poliovirus, coxsackie), ozone and ClO₂ can achieve 2–3 log inactivation within seconds to minutes (nepis.epa.gov), while adenovirus, which is highly UV-resistant (types 40/41), still requires tens of mJ for 1‑log even with UV (nepis.epa.gov). ClO₂ does not provide a long-lasting residual—it degrades quickly to chlorite—so it is usually applied as primary disinfection after filtration, followed by a small chlorine dose for residual (WHO) (nepis.epa.gov).

From a DBP perspective, ClO₂ does not form THM/HAA because it does not chlorinate organics. Its main by-products are chlorite (ClO₂⁻) and chlorate (ClO₃⁻) (nepis.epa.gov). WHO sets provisional guideline values of 0.7 mg/L for chlorite and chlorate in drinking water (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). Typical applications (doses of a few mg/L) produce chlorite in the range of a few tenths of a mg/L or less (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). Dose and purity control are very important because unreacted Cl₂ in the generation process can break down into these species (nepis.epa.gov).

Cost and implementation: ClO₂ must be produced on‑site (unstable gas), so a dedicated generator and dosing system are required. Capital cost is moderate; a historical example, a 780 gpm lab system ~US$9,670 (1979 dollars) (nepis.epa.gov)—at municipal scale this becomes tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars. O&M covers sodium chlorite, acid or chlorine feedstock, and electricity; consumption ranges from a few kg per 10⁶ m³. Pump/analyzer maintenance is relatively moderate compared with ozone/UV. Advantages: broad-spectrum efficacy, THMs greatly reduced, and it also helps with taste/odor and Fe/Mn (nepis.epa.gov). Limitations: complexity of on‑site generation, potential for chlorite/chlorate to exceed health limits when overdosed (nepis.epa.gov) (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov), it leaves no residual, and there is a risk of on‑site explosion at the installation (the generator requires maintenance).

Ozonation (O₃): highest potential, bromate constraint

Ozone is a very strong disinfectant/oxidizer; it oxidizes microbial cell walls and viral capsids (e.g. by attacking double bonds) (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). EPA data show that ozone achieves multi‑log inactivation of bacteria, viruses, and protozoa faster (lower CT) than chlorine or ClO₂ (nepis.epa.gov). Example: 1‑log Giardia at 10°C requires CT≈42 mg·min/L (chlorine) but only ~0.48 mg·min/L with ozone (nepis.epa.gov). At μg/L concentrations, ozone can kill E. coli 10⁴-fold within minutes (nepis.epa.gov).

Viruses generally require a higher ozone dose than bacteria: 0.2–1.5 mg/L ozone (40 seconds) gives 2‑log inactivation of poliovirus, and 1.45 mg/L ozone gives >5‑log for coxsackie (nepis.epa.gov). Protozoa are the most difficult: Cryptosporidium is the most resistant to ozone (nepis.epa.gov), with a CT of ~1.2 mg·min/L for 2‑log (nepis.epa.gov)—about 25× the CT for Giardia (nepis.epa.gov). In general, the order of resistance is: bacteria < viruses < protozoa (nepis.epa.gov). Like UV, ozone leaves no residual—it breaks down within minutes—so the water is usually given a small dose of chlorine/monochloramine after ozonation.

Ozone DBPs are different: there are no THMs/HAAs, but bromate (BrO₃⁻) can form from bromide; the WHO guideline is 0.01 mg/L (10 μg/L) (WHO). Ozone can also form aldehydes, ketones, and organic acids—generally not regulated like bromate. Minimizing bromate is key: operating at a lower ozone dose, a shorter contact time, or a lower pH during ozonation can keep bromate below 0.01 mg/L. Because some organics are oxidized into biodegradable compounds, biological filtration after ozonation is often used.

Cost and implementation: ozone systems are capital-intensive and energy-intensive—they require an ozone generator (oxygen- or dry-air-based), an injection/contact chamber, and an off-gas destructor. As an illustration, an air-based generator plus a contact tank can cost around USD 2–5 per cubic meter of treated-water capacity, so a 100 MLD plant costs several million USD. Operating costs are dominated by energy: a typical ozone generator requires ~0.4–0.6 kWh/kg O₃; for reference, achieving an ozone residual of ~2 mg/L can require ~5–10 Wh per liter of water, so the electricity cost is equivalent to tens to hundreds of $/ML depending on the tariff. Maintenance (oxygen supply, vacuum pumps, corrosion-resistant materials) and routine replacement of corona components add to the cost. Its advantage: no chemical cost. Many large utilities—especially in Europe and Japan—adopt ozone for high-performance disinfection; there are even very large plants (≥100,000 m³/hour) in operation (nepis.epa.gov). Given its complexity, support packages such as water treatment ancillaries are often prepared from the initial design stage.

Ultraviolet (UV): no chemicals, no DBPs

UV (usually low-pressure mercury lamps at 254 nm) damages microbial DNA/RNA. It is very effective against protozoa: a UV dose of 1.6–2.5 mJ/cm² is enough for ~1-log Cryptosporidium/Giardia (nepis.epa.gov). By contrast, many viruses are relatively UV-resistant: the table (EPA) shows ~58 mJ/cm² for 1-log of a generic virus vs ~2.5 mJ/cm² for protozoa (nepis.epa.gov). Bench studies confirm this: coliphage MS-2 needs ~25 mJ/cm² for ~0.3-log inactivation (nepis.epa.gov), and stubborn adenovirus requires tens of mJ/cm² for 1-log (Meng & Gerba ~24–30 mJ/cm² for 1-log) (nepis.epa.gov). In practice, UV reactors are designed for 2–4 log virus inactivation (40–100 mJ/cm²), which also ensures >4 log for Giardia/Crypto. UV leaves no residual; WHO states that UV is “particularly effective at inactivating Cryptosporidium”—an organism that is highly resistant to chlorine (WHO).

UV does not form halogenated DBP (no THM/HAA) (nepis.epa.gov). At very high energy, nitrite/nitrate can be oxidised, but in common drinking water applications, chemical DBP are practically nil. Note: when UV is combined with chlorine (e.g. UV post‑chlorination or UV‑AOP), nitrosamine formation must be taken into account, but pure UV does not produce regulated DBP. To maintain UV transmittance (and prevent microbial shielding), turbidity/organic pre‑treatment is often optimised; modular options such as ultrafiltration (UF) and compact UV reactors make retrofitting easier.

UV cost and O&M are moderate. Example estimate (Cotton et al., 2001): an 11 MGD installation (~42 ML/day) ~US$1.2 million (www.unh.edu), while a 210 MGD plant ~US$17 million (www.unh.edu). Annual O&M for 11 MGD is around US$23,000/year (www.unh.edu); at large plants, lamp power (and ballast/pumps) is ~50–60% of O&M—for example 210 MGD, ~61% of O&M for power (www.unh.edu). Low‑pressure lamp life is ~9–12 months, requiring annual replacement. Energy 0.02–0.05 kWh/m³; UV O&M is cheaper than ozone, but more expensive than chlorine.

Comparison summary and distribution system residual

  • Pathogen effectiveness:
    • Chlorine: bacteria are highly susceptible; viruses are easily inactivated; Cryptosporidium essentially not (same source: WHO). CT for 1‑log Giardia ~21–42 mg·min/L (10–20°C) (nepis.epa.gov) (nepis.epa.gov).
    • ClO₂: broad spectrum; ~4× more effective than Cl₂ against Giardia (nepis.epa.gov); effective against viruses, although some still require high doses (nepis.epa.gov).
    • Ozone: most potent; 1‑log Giardia CT ~0.2–0.5 mg·min/L (nepis.epa.gov). Resistance order: bacteria < viruses < protozoa (nepis.epa.gov) (nepis.epa.gov).
    • UV: effective for all classes; especially effective against protozoa (2–5 mJ/cm² for 1‑log Crypto/Giardia) (nepis.epa.gov); viruses require a much higher dose (tens of mJ) (nepis.epa.gov) (nepis.epa.gov).
  • DBPs and by‑products:
    • Chlorine: high THM/HAA formation; hundreds of DBPs (chloroform, HAA, etc.) (WHO); WHO example 200 μg/L for chloroform; many countries ~80 μg/L total THM.
    • ClO₂: almost no halogenated DBPs; oxychlorine by‑products—chlorite and chlorate—each 0.7 mg/L (WHO, provisional) (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov).
    • Ozone: does not form THM/HAA, but bromate can form; limit ~0.01 mg/L (10 μg/L) (WHO).
    • UV: practically no regulated DBPs—does not produce THM/HAA (nepis.epa.gov).
  • Residual in the network:
    • Chlorine: residual present (free chlorine or chloramine); typical residual ~0.2–0.5 mg/L.
    • ClO₂/ozone/UV: no residual; a small dose of chlorine is usually added post‑process. If the downstream process is chlorine-sensitive, a neutralizing agent such as a dechlorination agent is prepared at the final stage.
  • Capital and operating costs (indicative scale):
    • Chlorine: very low capex (feed system + contact tank can be <US$10,000 at small scale) (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). Low opex (~US$0.01–0.05/m³; energy almost zero).
    • ClO₂: moderate capex (on‑site generator, tens of thousands of USD for several ML/day); medium opex (chemicals + electricity).
    • Ozone: high capex (millions of USD for large plants); high opex (energy several kWh per kg O₃; energy can be ~US$5–15/ML depending on dose).
    • UV: moderate capex (~US$1.2 million for 11 MGD; ~US$17 million for 210 MGD) (www.unh.edu) (www.unh.edu); medium Opex (for example, 11 MGD ~US$23,000/year; power share ~50–60% at large plants) (www.unh.edu).
  • Operational notes:
    • Chlorine is easy to monitor, but DBP risk drives alternatives. Chloramine is usually a secondary disinfectant and can form nitrosamines (WHO).
    • ClO₂ is effective and suppresses THM, but watch chlorite/chlorate; it requires on‑site generation and maintenance; there is an on‑site explosion risk.
    • Ozone requires off‑gas management (toxic) and corrosion-resistant materials.
    • UV is sensitive to UV transmittance (turbidity/organics) and requires lamp/sleeve maintenance; compact, modular reactors make retrofit easier.

Design implications for utilities and PDAM

Every utility must weigh this trade‑off. Small systems with low organic load often still use chlorine because of simplicity and cost (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). Large cities pursuing maximum inactivation performance and DBP control tend to consider UV or ozone even though the cost is higher. Indonesian regulations currently follow WHO/ISO guidelines (for example, requiring a residual ≥0.5 mg/L—see the WHO link: WHO), so most PDAM utilities still use chlorination or chloramination for residual protection. However, when emerging contaminants appear or strict DBP limits drive design, ozone or UV as a primary barrier is increasingly considered. In all cases, the decision is based on raw water quality (organics, bromide, turbidity), inactivation targets (e.g. Giardia removal), DBP regulations, and lifecycle cost—and is often combined with pretreatment optimization through activated carbon media and sand/silica filtration before disinfection.

To design a disinfection and pretreatment combination suited to raw water quality, we provide water treatment for coal-fired power plants and industrial WTP and water treatment chemicals. For small installations or retrofits, UV and cartridge UV systems are available.

Source references

The summary and figures refer to authoritative reviews/guidelines (WHO, EPA, NRC) and UV cost analysis. Example: the U.S. EPA Disinfection/DBP Rule Technical Document presents a CT comparison (e.g., chlorine vs ozone for Giardia) (nepis.epa.gov); WHO guidelines list DBP limits (bromate 10 μg/L, chlorite 700 μg/L) (WHO) (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov); engineering studies review UV capex/O&M (www.unh.edu) (www.unh.edu). These data support quantitative, site-specific selection of disinfection technology.