WhatsApp

Article

Inside the water kill chain: how food plants stack chlorination, UV, and ozone to hit drinking‑water safety

beta-pramesti-asiaindustry-food-and-beverageprocess-raw-water-treatment

Raw Water Disinfection at F&B Plants: Chlorine, UV, or Ozone? The Strategy Is Multi‑Barrier

Water in food and beverage plants is both a raw material and a cleaning agent—if it is not safe, products and public health are at risk. The three main disinfection technologies—chlorination, UV, and ozone—have advantages and disadvantages; the key is a multi-barrier approach.

In the F&B industry, water affects taste, aroma, appearance, shelf life, and product safety (water.co.id). Indonesian standards target drinking-water quality—zero E. coli/coliform in 100 mL, very low turbidity, and chemical thresholds including Trihalomethanes/THMs ≤100 µg/L according to WHO guidelines—with reference to Permenkes 492/2010 (www.kemkes.go.id). Because raw water is rarely “perfect,” disinfection is a mandatory step.

No single method solves all problems at once. Chlorine is inexpensive and effective against bacteria/viruses, UV is reliable for chlorine-resistant pathogens such as Cryptosporidium, and ozone is powerful and also oxidizes organics. Their combination—multi-barrier—ensures ≥4–6 log reduction (logarithmic reduction; 1 log = 90%) against pathogens under variable source conditions (WHO Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality).

Before comparing technologies, physical pretreatment—screening, coagulation, and media or membrane filtration—in practice improves the chances of success. Membrane systems are often used to filter particles/organics that interfere with downstream disinfection.

Chlorination spectrum and performance

Chlorination (gas, NaOCl/liquid, hypochlorite) is the standard for the water industry: “chlorination is the standard against which others are compared” (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). Its mechanism is oxidation of cell components. Under the right conditions, bacteria and many viruses can achieve >3–5 log inactivation; CT (concentration×time; concentration×contact time) for 4‑log E. coli at pH ~7 is about 3–5 mg·min/L, for example 1–2 mg/L Cl₂ for 2–5 minutes (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). In F&B practice, free residual is maintained at ~0.2–0.5 mg/L to protect the distribution network.

The drawbacks are real. Chlorine forms disinfection by-products/DBPs such as THMs and haloacetic acids when it reacts with organic matter; WHO and the U.S. EPA limit total THMs to ~0.1 mg/L. Since the 1970s, the discovery of THMs has prompted “reexamination of available disinfection methodology” (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). The pathogen spectrum is also limited: Cryptosporidium oocysts are essentially resistant—a CT of 3000–4000 mg·min/L achieves only 90% inactivation, and chlorine has been shown to be “largely ineffective against Cryptosporidium” (waterworld.com). Chlorine taste/odor is often undesirable in beverages, and chlorite/chlorate formation occurs when chloramine or chlorine dioxide is used.

In terms of cost, chlorination is usually the cheapest per m³; investment and energy are minimal. However, logistics remain: “two liters of 5% NaOCl must be stored per ML of water to dose 2–5 mg/L.” An academic review also concludes that chlorine is the “preferred option” because of its ease of use, but other technologies (chloramines, ozone, UV) are used to reduce DBPs (researchgate.net). For DBP control, pretreatment for organics—for example, activated carbon media—is often included before or after chlorination.

Keeping CT and residual correct requires dose control; devices such as a dosing pump help keep the concentration stable without causing overshoot that triggers DBP formation, and continuous monitoring such as Betaqua Sentinel WS ensures dose deviations are visible quickly.

UV-C 254 nm: no chemicals and no DBPs

Ultraviolet (UV-C) damages microbial DNA/RNA and is effective against bacteria, viruses, and protozoa. A dose of ~40 mJ/cm² usually gives ~3-log (99.9%) inactivation of Giardia cysts and Cryptosporidium oocysts (waterworld.com), while some adenoviruses/spores require up to ~100 mJ/cm² for 5-log. UV adds no chemicals or DBPs and is common in the beverage/pharmaceutical industry (WHO GDWQ). Modern low‑pressure lamp life is ~9,000–12,000 hours with predictable maintenance intervals (enviroliteracy.org).

Its limitation: no residual. Once it leaves the reactor, water can be recontaminated in pipes/storage, so UV is ideal as a “final polish” with an additional barrier if needed. UV also needs very clear water; turbidity and particles can shield microbes. For that reason, pre-filtration or clarification is almost always required—typically media filtration such as sand/silica filter—for the UV system to work optimally.

Energy and O&M: low‑pressure installations ~100–250 kWh per million gallons (MG); medium‑pressure ~460–560 kWh/MG (enviroliteracy.org). For comparison, chlorination systems use about 60–250 kWh/MG for pumping/mixing (enviroliteracy.org). Flow variation requires a UV reactor and controls that can maintain the design dose at peak flow.

Ozonation: a strong oxidant, with no residual

Ozone (O₃) is generated on‑site (corona discharge), injected into the water, and then breaks down quickly into O₂—practically no long-term residual. Ozone oxidizes cell walls and organics; it sterilizes microbes quickly while reducing taste/odor compounds, and oxidizes Fe/Mn so they are easier to remove. Compared with chlorine for tough protozoa, the ozone CT requirement is much lower than the chlorine CT of ~3000–4000 mg·min/L that gives only 90% Giardia/Crypto kill.

A typical dose of 1–5 mg/L with 5–10 minutes of contact can give multi‑log kill of bacteria and high kill of viruses. Relative effectiveness is not sensitive at pH 6–8.5 and increases at warmer temperatures. Ozone produces far fewer halogenated DBPs than chlorine, and even reduces chlorine DBP precursors when placed upstream (WHO GDWQ).

Operational note: no residual means an additional barrier is needed for the risk of recontamination. Dose must be monitored closely; excess ozone can form bromate if bromide is present (a regulated parameter). Residual ozone must be quenched or off‑gassed because it is toxic; systems usually include an ozone destruct/monitor. The energy cost of commercial generators is ~2–5 kWh/kg O₃; it is usually more expensive per m³ than chlorination, depending on scale.

Complementary multi‑barrier design

No single disinfectant is superior against all pathogens/conditions. For that reason, a multi‑barrier approach—a chain of physical and chemical/UV layers—is standard practice in F&B. If one step underperforms, the others still maintain quality.

General scheme: screening → coagulation/clarification → media or membrane filtration → dual disinfection. Many facilities choose coarse pre‑screening, followed by media filtration or ultrafiltration (UF), then final disinfection (UV, ozone, or chlorine). One common example sequence: automatic screen 300 micron → inline coagulation → ultrafiltration membrane (absolute pore size 0.02–0.1 µm) → chlorine dosing. The UF stage provides a physical barrier with >6‑log capability for bacteria/protozoa, and downstream chlorine residual ensures re‑growth is inactivated.

In chains that use coagulation and clarification, units such as a clarifier are often used; “coagulation” here usually uses a coagulant (example link: PAC) before filtration. For turbid river sources, the combination “coagulation/sedimentation → filtration → UV → chlorine” improves end‑to‑end quality assurance.

The effect is multiplicative: if filtration removes 2 log coliform and UV adds 3 log, the total is 5 log (99.999%). Another example, 3‑log UV for Crypto + 3‑log removal by filtration + 2‑log inactivation by chlorine gives ~8‑log total (99.999999%)—exceeding the ~4‑log Crypto removal commonly required.

This practice aligns with WHO guidelines and regulations (e.g. US EPA Long Term 2, Water Safety Plans) and also targets biofilm in pipes/storage that can protect Listeria/E. coli from routine cleaning. Biofilm is a microbial community embedded in a polymer matrix that can release cells into the main stream, triggering product contamination (digitaledition.food-safety.com). Continuous chlorine residual dosing or periodic ozone/UV in the CIP loop helps break up biofilm.

Practical scheme and outcome metrics

Example practical configuration: raw water → sand/carbon filter (reduce turbidity/organics) → UV reactor ~40–60 mJ/cm² → chlorine residual 0.2–0.5 mg/L. Here, filtration prevents “UV shadowing”, UV kills quickly, and chlorine protects during storage/distribution. Another alternative, ozone + chlorine: ozone oxidizes contaminants and inactivates >99.99% of microbes, then a small chlorine dose as residual; pre‑ozonation also reduces chlorine DBP precursors.

When implemented correctly, multi‑barrier brings “potable water” quality into the plant. Parameters usually monitored afterward: total coliform = 0 CFU/100 mL, turbidity <0.1 NTU, THMs below the limit, and microbial challenge tests (spiked counts) that fall by several orders of magnitude. The global F&B trend adopts UV and ozone in multi‑barrier schemes for higher product purity and to avoid chlorine taste.

In Indonesia, compliance with Permenkes and SNI (zero pathogens, certain chemical limits) is commonly achieved by a layered treatment train like this. Data-driven design—using CT tables, log-removal targets, and pilot testing—allows engineers to size chlorinators, UV reactors, or ozone generators so that combined performance reaches the desired safety margin. Final risk target: a negligible waterborne infection rate, with a tolerable burden of disease <10^–6 DALY (disability-adjusted life years) per person-year according to WHO water safety goals (WHO GDWQ).

Source notes and reference figures

References cited for quality, energy, and performance: NAS/UK standards and studies on chlorination and DBP (www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov), UV dose for Crypto 40 mJ/cm² (waterworld.com), WHO drinking water guidelines (WHO GDWQ), U.S. EPA DBP limits (EPA NPDWR), biofilm and contamination (digitaledition.food-safety.com), and UV energy consumption and comparison with chlorination (enviroliteracy.org). The description of water's role in F&B refers to (water.co.id) and compliance with Permenkes to (www.kemkes.go.id).