WhatsApp

Article

Food plants are turning BOD into biogas — and hitting stricter discharge limits — with a three‑stage cleanup

beta-pramesti-asiaindustry-food-and-beverageprocess-process-wastewater-treatment

From BOD to Biogas: A Multi-Stage WWTP Design That Cleans Up F&B Effluent

4–6 hours of equalization, high-rate UASB/EGSB, then aerobic polishing with SBR/MBR: this three-stage scheme converts organics into renewable energy and closes the BOD, N, and P gaps to strict limits.

Imagine 1,000 kg/day of COD entering a food factory's WWTP. With the right design, that is equivalent to ~300 m³/day of CH₄ (≈3,000 kWh), and the residual organic load after MBR is <20 kg/day—while effluent reaches BOD/TSS <20–30 mg/L, NH₃–N <5–10 mg/L, and TP in the range of a few mg/L. That is the logic of multi-stage design: equalization buffer, high-rate anaerobic conversion, followed by aerobic polishing.

In many implementations, organic reduction is very high—with effluent COD near zero and robust nutrient removal—while producing renewable energy from biogas. Indonesian standards (Permen LH 5/2014) serve as the quality guardrail, while technical approval and the Surat Kelayakan Operasional (SLO) follow Permen LHK No. 5 Tahun 2021 for activities that discharge or reuse wastewater in accordance with Article 3 and the screening provisions in its annex.

Flow and load equalization

Diurnal and per-batch fluctuations are common in F&B; therefore, a mixed equalization tank (EQ, flow/load equalizer) is a mandatory “buffer.” Its size is usually several hours of average flow—often 4–6 hours—to dampen load peaks (4enveng.com). The tank is kept mixed (usually aerated) so that the outflow is stable and pH fluctuations are masked, allowing downstream units to work as designed.

As a bonus, aeration in EQ often provides in-situ BOD reduction of 10–20% via endogenous degradation (4enveng.com). In one snack factory case study, the initial equalization tank was eventually cut in half after monitoring showed the initial volume was far too large—some of the load had even been removed by DAF before EQ (accesswater.org). Dissolved air flotation technology is available commercially, for example DAF.

Regulatory note: wastewater quality standards refer to Permen LH No. 5 Tahun 2014 tentang Baku Mutu Air Limbah (peraturan.bpk.go.id), while technical approval and the Operational Feasibility Letter (SLO) for environmental pollution control refer to Permen LHK No. 5 Tahun 2021 tentang Tata Cara Penerbitan Persetujuan Teknis dan Surat Kelayakan Operasional Bidang Pengendalian Pencemaran Lingkungan (peraturan.bpk.go.id). That obligation applies to activities that discharge or reuse wastewater under Article 3, taking into account the screening provisions in its appendix—Appendix I (pp. 57–58) opens a route for an integrated wastewater treatment plant (IPAL) without a separate technical approval, so pre-treatment alone does not trigger that obligation.

High-rate anaerobic reactors (UASB/EGSB)

After EQ, most organic carbon (BOD/COD) is processed anaerobically. High-rate reactors—especially UASB (upflow anaerobic sludge blanket) or EGSB (expanded granular sludge bed)—are well suited to food wastewater because of their high loading capacity (mdpi.com). Typical high F&B loads (often 1,000–4,000 mg/L BOD; mdpi.com) can be handled by retaining granular methanogenic biomass under mesophilic conditions (~30–35 °C). Under optimal conditions—HRT (hydraulic retention time) of a few hours to ~1 day; OLR (organic loading rate) ~4–10 gCOD·L⁻¹·day—COD/BOD removal reaches ~90–98%.

For example, Lu et al. (2015) reported 98.7% total COD removal in a UASB at an HRT of 6 hours for starch wastewater (influent COD 1,000 mg/L; OLR 4 g·L⁻¹·day) (mdpi.com). Xu et al. (2023) showed that an EGSB could maintain ~96% COD removal when the OLR was increased from ~5.6 to 12.6 gCOD·L⁻¹·day (HRT 1.4–3.9 days) (mdpi.com). Another study (e.g., Musa et al., 2019) also recorded ~90% removal at an OLR of ~5 g·L⁻¹·day, with performance declining gradually at very high loads (mdpi.com).

As organic matter is consumed, the reactor produces biogas (≈CH₄ + CO₂). Typical yield is 0.25–0.35 L CH₄ per gram of COD removed (mdpi.com)—about 0.3 m³ CH₄ per kg COD, or an energy equivalent of ~3–4 kWh per kg COD. In the Lu et al. study above, CH₄ reached 0.33 L/g COD (mdpi.com). Overall, about 60–75% of influent BOD can be converted to methane; the biogas itself is usually 60–70% CH₄. He et al. estimate that at influent COD >~13–15 g/L, an anaerobic system can break even on energy and even have a surplus if the biogas is used (mdpi.com).

PT Beta Pramesti Asia assesses organic load, biodegradability, temperature, toxicity, alkalinity, gas, and polishing requirements before designing the Sistem Anaerob Air Limbah Industri for this stage.

Note: UASB effluent often requires post‑treatment because it still carries significant dissolved COD and hydrogen sulfide—reviews emphasize “UASB effluent often requires post‑treatment” (mdpi.com)—and essentially all nitrogen (ammonia) remains. In one UASB test in a warm climate, <25% of total nitrogen was removed anaerobically (mdpi.com). A subsequent aerobic stage is needed for polishing and for nitrification/denitrification and phosphorus treatment.

Aerobic polishing (SBR or MBR)

This final stage targets residual BOD/COD, TSS, ammonia-N, and phosphorus. Two common options: SBR (sequencing batch reactor) and MBR (membrane bioreactor). With adequate aeration and high solids retention, BOD/COD falls to single digits or the teens in mg/L.

In a pilot study of a hollow-fiber MBR for F&B wastewater, COD/TSS rejection reached 84–95% and the effluent met the industrial BOD standard (researchgate.net). Combining UASB with activated sludge polishing (essentially a continuous SBR) produces effluent COD of ≈0.05 g/L (50 mg/L), with total COD removal of 67–97% and total nitrogen removal of ~87–93% (mdpi.com).

Modern SBRs with anoxic/aerobic cycles routinely achieve ≈70–90% ammonia removal and significant P uptake; package solutions are available as SBR or as part of the Sistem Aerob Air Limbah Industri. Alternatively, MBR maintains high biomass (MLSS ~8–12 g/L), so turbidity and residual BOD are very low (often <10–20 mg/L) while ensuring nearly complete nitrification—the MBR portfolio is designed for reuse quality.

For dairy applications, the UASB–MBR hybrid shows >95% removal of soluble COD and equally high TN (mdpi.com). In practice, typical performance of the aerobic stage: BOD/TSS <20–30 mg/L, NH₃–N <5–10 mg/L, and TP of a few mg/L—enough for strict discharge limits. This polishing is also commonly packaged as activated sludge for easy integration.

Performance and business results

This multi-stage scheme provides very high organic reduction, with effluent COD near zero and strong nutrient removal. About 90–98% of incoming BOD is converted to biogas (renewable energy), so the facility's energy needs can be offset, and final BOD can be reduced to <20–30 mg/L. Implementations based on this concept routinely report >95% removal of “5‑day BOD” and >80% total nitrogen removal (mdpi.com; researchgate.net).

In terms of sizing, a data-based approach makes estimation easier: 1,000 kg/day influent COD will produce ~300 m³/day CH₄ (≈3,000 kWh), and MBR for polishing will leave <20 kg/day organic load. Compliance with local standards (Permen 5/2014 in Indonesia) is achieved with margin, while opening opportunities for renewable energy credits and stable operation (peraturan.bpk.go.id).

Reference basis

All figures and performance results above are supported by the following peer‑reviewed/regulatory sources: mdpi.com; 4enveng.com; mdpi.com; mdpi.com; mdpi.com; researchgate.net; 4enveng.com; accesswater.org; mdpi.com; and the regulation Permen LH No. 5 Tahun 2014.